The numbers tell a sobering story. While 92% of executives plan to increase AI spending over the next three years, the vast majority won’t see meaningful returns. Recent research reveals that only one in four AI initiatives achieve expected growth targets. A staggering 95% of GenAI projects deliver no measurable ROI whatsoever.
This isn’t a signal that AI doesn’t work. It’s evidence of a measurement problem. The value exists, but without proper tracking and proof points, it remains invisible to leadership and investors.
For Irish enterprises navigating this landscape, the challenge is clear: how do you move from AI aspiration to measurable business impact?
“Irish businesses are brilliant at innovation, but we need to get better at proving it,” says Mark Kelly, founder of AI Ireland. “The companies seeing real returns from AI aren’t the ones with the biggest budgets or the fanciest models. They’re the ones who set clear metrics from day one and actually track them. That discipline is what separates success stories from expensive experiments.“
The Measurement Gap
The difference between top-performing AI implementations and those struggling to break even is dramatic. Whilst enterprise AI investments average 2.3 times ROI over three years, leading organisations achieve returns of 5.8 times their investment. Meanwhile, many companies barely break even.
The dividing line isn’t technology sophistication or budget size. It comes down to two critical factors: measurement and adoption.
Measurement defines what success looks like and quantifies impact through business-aligned KPIs. Adoption ensures those gains materialise through workforce enablement, workflow redesign, and strategic redeployment of saved time.
Think of it as a simple equation: Measurement + Adoption = AI ROI
Setting the Right Business Objectives
Before discussing metrics or models, Irish enterprises need clarity on what they’re trying to achieve. AI investments typically serve three purposes:
Saving Money: AI drives efficiency by automating routine tasks and increasing throughput without expanding headcount. For example, if sales representatives reclaim eight to ten hours weekly through automated outreach and follow-ups, they gain an entire day for high-value prospecting and closing.
Making Money: Beyond cost reduction, AI accelerates revenue growth through improved customer experiences, personalised recommendations and higher conversion rates. Even modest improvements compound across large customer bases. An AI support agent that reduces customer effort can simultaneously lower churn and increase lifetime value.
Reducing Risk: For some organisations, the highest priority is operational protection. AI detects anomalies, enforces compliance and flags issues early. If anomaly detection cuts mean time to detect from 14 days to two days, and each day of exposure costs €15,000, you avoid €180,000 per incident.
The Framework That Works
Successful AI measurement follows a structured approach:
Define Your Primary Goal: Select the specific workflow or use case you want to improve. Clarify what success looks like and what gains you expect.
Choose the Right KPIs: Pick three to five metrics that prove impact on your primary goal. If you’re focused on cost savings, track efficiency and productivity gains. For revenue growth, monitor conversion rates and customer lifetime value. Risk mitigation requires tracking incident frequency and response times.
Establish Your Baseline: Before AI implementation, create a reliable benchmark by tracking time, cost, volume, error rate and revenue over eight to twelve weeks.
Set Clear Targets: Define expected improvements, whether that’s a 25% reduction in workflow time, 10% increase in conversion, or 40% drop in incident rate.
Track Continuously: Monitor the same KPIs weekly, comparing results to baseline to spot early wins and make timely adjustments.
Translate to Financial Impact: Every stakeholder speaks the language of euros. Hours saved becomes reduced labour costs. Conversion lift translates to additional revenue. Reduced risk equals avoided costs.
From Metrics to Money
Consider a practical example: A consulting firm with 35 analysts discovers each spends 30 hours drafting cases, producing five cases weekly across 50 weeks annually. That’s 7,500 analyst hours per year at €125 per hour, totalling €937,500 in labour costs.
By implementing AI agents for research and drafting, they reduce time per case by 25%, saving 1,875 hours annually. At €125 per hour, that’s €234,375 in annual labour savings against a €330,000 investment.
The ROI calculations reveal:
- Simple ROI after three years: 113% return
- Payback period: 1.41 years
- Net Present Value: €274,000
- Internal Rate of Return: 32%
This 32% return significantly exceeds the typical enterprise hurdle rate of 8-12%, making it a compelling investment even accounting for risk and adoption challenges.
The Adoption Challenge
Here’s the uncomfortable truth: ROI dies without usage. Theoretical savings only materialise when employees actually adopt and effectively use AI tools.
Research shows that trained employees are 1.9 times more likely to report business value, with 43% using AI daily compared to less than 1% of untrained teams. As one CTO puts it: “If people aren’t adopting AI, you’re not getting any impact.”
A structured 90-day adoption playbook helps bridge this gap:
Weeks 0-2 (Foundation): Centralise access through single sign-on, approve tools and models, establish guardrails and define success criteria. This creates a measurable baseline for future ROI reporting.
Weeks 3-6 (Training): Deliver role-based training tailored to specific workflows, develop core prompting and verification skills, require certification and support ongoing adoption through office hours and peer champions.
Weeks 7-12 (Validation): Measure performance against KPIs, correlate usage with outcomes, share internal proof points, and refine assumptions based on actual versus forecasted results.
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
Irish enterprises should watch for these frequent traps:
Not Planning Where Saved Time Goes: Efficiency only creates ROI when reclaimed hours generate additional value. Define how saved time will be redeployed before rollout.
One-Size-Fits-All Thinking: Different AI models have different strengths. Using the wrong model for the wrong task leads to slower performance and inconsistent results that dilute returns.
Skipping Training: Low adoption and poor outputs stem from inadequate onboarding. Budget time for comprehensive training and celebrate early wins.
Underestimating Security Risks: Cheap or free tools may train on your data without consent, creating compliance risks and legal exposure that quickly outweigh short-term savings.
The Path Forward
Leading organisations now recover AI investments in six to twelve months, whilst less mature companies typically take up to 24 months. Studies show an average ROI of €3.70 for every euro invested, with top performers achieving up to €10.30 in return.
For Irish enterprises, the opportunity is substantial, but success requires discipline. Start with clear business objectives aligned to specific workflows. Establish baseline metrics before implementation. Train your workforce comprehensively. Track adoption and outcomes weekly. Convert performance improvements into financial terms that resonate across departments.
Most importantly, remember that AI tools don’t generate impact on their own – execution does. The technology enables transformation, but your people, processes and measurement systems determine whether potential becomes performance.
The 5% of organisations achieving exceptional AI ROI aren’t lucky. They’re methodical. They measure what matters, enable their teams, and maintain the discipline to track results from day one. With the right framework, Irish enterprises can join them.
Call to Action
If you’d like to delve deeper into how these trends can reshape your organisation, we would be delighted to discuss them in more detail. Invite Mark Kelly, Founder of AI Ireland, to speak at your next team meeting, conference or strategy session. We can explore practical ways to harness AI responsibly, meet sustainability goals, and navigate the evolving consumer landscape. Let’s work together to ensure Ireland remains at the vanguard of innovation in 2026 – and beyond.
Discover more from AI Ireland
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
